Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

Page Properties
label

Status

Status
colourYellowGreen
titleIN PROGRESSDECIDED

Description

Should we harmonize our default search profiles in Primo VE? If so, how should the default search profile be configured?

Decision

We recommend harmonizing the default search profile across campuses. The default search profile should be configured to include the IZ + NZ Physical/Electronic + CDI

Owning group

Discovery FG

Approver

PPC

Stakeholders

R = Discovery FG
A = WG
C =  Campus Discovery groups, Resource Management, Acquisitions & E-Resources, Fulfillment FG
I = End User Outreach Subgroup, Digital Collections FG

Decision-making process

  • Consulted with other consortia (University at Buffalo) and local UC campus groups for feedback

  • Compared configuration options and their impact on end user experience

  • Tested existing configurations at other Primo VE institutions (CSU, SUNY)

Priority

Mandatory before Go-live

Due date

02/15/

Recommendation

We do recommend harmonizing the default search profile across campuses. The default search profile should be configured to include the IZ (local collections) + NZ (entire network, both electronic and physical) + CDI

...

Harmonize default search profile?

No - do not harmonize

Yes - do harmonizeNot Harmonized

Harmonized

Training and end-user communication artifacts can be shared among campuses.

(minus)

(plus)

Reference staff helping patrons at another UC have a consistent experience.

(minus)

(plus)

Campuses can configure search profiles their own way.

(plus)

(minus)
Campuses with separate sites for small, special libraries (e.g. law or medical) can still chose a different default search profile for a home page.

...

Include network materials in the default search profile?

No - do not include.

Yes - do includeNetwork materials not included in default

Network materials are included in default

End users seeking a known item at another UC would discover it via the default search scope

(minus)

(plus)

End users would not need to understand search profiles in order to effectively use the system thereby improving the experience of novice users.

(minus)

(plus)

End users can surface content imported directly into the Network Zone via the default search scope, exposing users to content they may not have otherwise known was in the system (eg. digital collections such as Calisphere)

(minus)

(plus)

End users can discover eBooks and journals from CDL packages in the default search profile. +

(plus)

(plus)

Users will not be frustrated by finding eBooks only available at another UC

(plus)

(minus)

However, it’s possible for signed-in users to initiate purchase requests for campuses that want this enabled. It can be limited by user group, e.g. faculty.

Advanced end users who want to see only materials available to them locally do not have to use a facet to restrict their search results. *

(plus)

(minus)

...

Include CDI in the default search profile?

No - do not include.

Yes - do include.CDI materials not included in default

CDI materials are included in default

End users would discover articles, book chapters, music, and other CDI items in the default search profile.

(minus)

(plus)

Aligns with end users' expectation (as seen in catalog analytics data and described in the literature) of a “single search” experience for finding library materials.

(minus)

(plus)

End users would not need to understand search profiles in order to effectively use the system thereby improving the experience of novice users.

(minus)

(plus)

Advanced end users who only want to see books or other local material in their search results will not have to use a facet to restrict their results set. *

(plus)

(minus)

Advanced, known-item type search results may sometimes defy user expectations (such as book review records appearing above the record for the book)

(plus)

(minus)

However, during the test-load phase campuses will test the local boosting in Primo to see if it alleviates some known issues with more advanced searches.

...

Action/Point Person

Expected Completion Date

Notes

Status

Create document summarizing Primo Search Profile configuration options

12/11/2020

Primo Search Profiles Overview document shared in Google Drive

Complete

Ask Primo listserv for consortial experiences

01/06/2021

Complete

Deliver summary document to campus stakeholders and discuss end user needs for discovery / All Discovery FG members

01/15/2021

Complete

Consult with Resource Management, Acquisitions & E-Resources, and Fulfillment groups

02/0210/2021

PPC for approval

02/19/2021