Authority Control in the NZ

See Best Practices for Decision Pages and Tags for groups
Legend: not started IN PROGRESS STALLED decided

Status

not started

Description

Determine the best way to move forward with authority control in the NZ

Decision summary

 

Owning group

RM-OST

Approver

 

Consulted

 

Informed

 

Decision-making process

 

Priority

 

Target decision date

 

Date decided

[type // to add Date]

Recommendation

Impact

Stakeholder group

Impact

Stakeholder group

Impact

 

 

 

 

Reasoning

 

Background

Relevant Ex Libris documentation:

Current relevant NZ configurations:

  • The “Authorities - Handle Local Authority Record Updates” and “Authorities - Link BIB Headings” jobs are both enabled and run daily.

  • However, the “Authorities - Preferred Term Correction” job is disabled, since it was determined to introduce too many errors. (See Harvard’s documentation for a list of issues).

The SILS Landscape

The implementation decision ( ) had an ambitious plan to generate monthly spreadsheets based on the NZ Authority Control Task List. However, since the implementation of , the scope of the Authority Control Task List (ACTL) has become too massive to even consider exporting them.

Example:

For a single week (10/09/2003-10/16/2023), there are 344,914 items in the ACTL.

Attempting to narrow the results down through the available filters can help, but the number of items is still overwhelming.

  • Suppressed from Discovery - No

  • Linked to Community Zone - No

Report type

Vocabulary

Number of items for controlled fields (excluding 880s)

Report type

Vocabulary

Number of items for controlled fields (excluding 880s)

AUT record deleted - Unlinked BIB heading

LCNAMES

145

BIB heading found multiple matching AUT headings (ambiguous)

LCNAMES

490

BIB heading found multiple matching AUT headings (ambiguous)

LCSH

82

BIB heading found multiple matching AUT headings (ambiguous)

LCGFT

13

BIB heading found no matching AUT headings

LCNAMES

24,282

BIB heading found no matching AUT headings

MESH

320

BIB heading found no matching AUT headings

LCSH

3,234

BIB heading found no matching AUT headings

LCGFT

432

The ACTL does not show any information about which campuses have holdings on a particular record--you must search for the MMS ID to see holdings.

The NZ ACTL can only be accessed through the NZ instance of Alma--individual campus IZs can only see a version of the ACTL for their records that are not linked to the NZ.

Analytics does not provide any of the information available in the ACTL.

Many campuses regularly perform authority work at the time of cataloging (e.g., creating an authority record for a name come across in daily work).

But the bulk of the database maintenance work (i.e., ensuring that legacy records continue to be updated with current forms of headings) has now mostly been abandoned, with the hope that our WorldCat Daily Updates will take care of it.

What is still desired?

  • (UCLA): Since many of our records come in through vendor loads or are processed by student workers, we would like to be able to review headings for records recently cataloged in our collection that may have issues so we can address them. This was possible in our last system (Voyager) with the help of our authority vendor (Backstage Library Works). It does not appear to be possible in our current implementation of Alma.

Options Considered [remove if not needed]

 

Option 1

Option 2

 

Option 1

Option 2

Description

 

 

Pros

 

 

Cons

 

 

Dependencies

 

Questions to consider

 

Action Log

Action/Point Person

Expected Completion Date

Notes

Status

Action/Point Person

Expected Completion Date

Notes

Status

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The SILS mission is to transform library services and operations through innovation and collaboration. The future is shared!
Question? Contact AskSILS-L@ucop.edu