2023-04-20 Meeting notes

Attendees

  • Jharina Pascual, (acting vice-chair) UCI

  • Sarah Sheets, UCM

  • Michelle Polchow, Chair, UCD

  • Sherry Lochhaas, CDL

  • Natalee Bell, UCSB

  • Kevin Balster, UCLA

  • Jason Dezember, UCB

  • Sarah Lindsey, UCSC (substituting for Tamara)

  • Judy Keys, UCSD

  • Carla Arbagey, UCR

  • Katie Keyser, UCSF

Not in attendance:

  • Tamara Pilko, Vice Chair, UCSC (on leave)

Meeting documents:
Meeting Recording & Chat (link to file in Google Drive)

Item

Desired Outcome

Time

Who

Notes

Decisions

Actions

 

 

Item

Desired Outcome

Time

Who

Notes

Decisions

Actions

 

 

1

Record: Michelle




Share announcements

 

10 min

 

Note taker: Kevin
Timekeeper: Sarah Sheets

  • Michelle: Lisa Spagnolo was in an accident, and will be out for quite a while to recover. Can reach out to her over Slack.

  • CDL NZ TF has received extension for investigating order records in the NZ.

  • Michelle: Need to check schedule for May

    • MP: out for ELUNA and NASIG

    • CA: out for ELUNA

    • JP: out for NASIG

    • Cancel meetings on the11th and 25th

    • Meet the 4th and 18th

  • KB: UL is retiring at the end of December

 

 

 

 

2

Multi-Part E-Collections
Decision Page




Goals in escalation:

  • SILS communication

  • SILS prioritization

  • Assess systematic perspective beyond ERES

  • Clarity in coordination between SILS & CDL

  • Technical improvements in deliverable template- status “escalate”

 

 

20 min

@Michelle Polchow

  • Initiated by CDL who needed feedback on how to represent large sets of e-collections in Primo (e.g., JSTOR, Sage)

  • Feedback from campuses were collection specific and sometimes contradictory

  • reason for escalation: have OT do project management to develop policies that could be used widely

  • Biggest impact is on Discovery

  • ERES work should focus on “how” to implement goals/best practices, not develop the policies and determine “why” things should happen

  • MP: maybe there needs to be an “escalation” status on decision pages. Escalation doesn’t seem to be easily accomplished.

  • SL: ERES has assessed that this isn’t something we can accomplish, so support sending to OT

  • SL (SC): ERES got a lot of topics with overlap with other groups. Need for escalation hasn’t come up often in other groups

  • SL (CDL): what information has recently changed? Want to review before sending to OT

    • MP: what was discussed in Steering

  • MP: Have review done before All Chairs meeting on 5/9

 

 

 

 

3

Sharing of E-Resources Licensing Information Across UC
Decision Page

Goals in escalation

 

20 min

  • MP: vision of AEFG is that there would be a Box account where licenses could go. But ignores ability to make is scalable.

  • Focus shifted to having well-known lines of communication for campuses to connect as needed. Have a listserv. Davis hosted a listserv, but desire to have a central list hosted by CDL

  • Issue revolves around whether licenses could be shared across all campuses (whether we’re considered one university or separate). Need decision on this from higher above

  • SL (CDL): Licensing CKG could be a good idea, but doesn’t need to go through SILS structure. following up on legal question about sharing across campuses. Reviewing CDL’s original decision to not host list. Very little activity on the list.

  • NB: Find it more efficient to reach out to campus directly rather than use listserv

  • MP: if this ends up being not a SILS issue (for example, creating a CKG), better for OT to report that out

  • JP: CKG could be useful, since it’s not always just about language on specific license. Can discuss larger policy questions

  • SL (CDL): CDL has page with licensing liaisons: https://cdlib.org/groups/licensing-liaisons/ . Let CDL know if campus liaison needs to be updated

  • CA: OA group is seeing lots of decisions needed from groups that don’t really exist. Potentially need other groups, but everybody is already overstretched, so not sure how to address

  • MP: ERES could become overarching group

  • JP: OT seems to be the one designed for these cross-group decisions.

 

 

 

 

4

Wrap Up

Review actions and decisions

10 min

 

 

 

 

 

 

5

Parking Lot

Capture important topics for future discussion:

 

 

  • MP will update multi-collection decision page

  • JP will update licensing decision page

 

@Paula Pascual to update licensing page

@Michelle Polchow to update multi-collection decision page

 

 

 

6

 

Total

60/60

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The SILS mission is to transform library services and operations through innovation and collaboration. The future is shared!
Question? Contact AskSILS-L@ucop.edu